The Boston Bruins first move of the offseason after missing the playoffs for the second straight year was to promptly go out and resign unrestricted free agent to be Kevan Miller - one of the B's most unpopular players among fans.
Not only did GM Don Sweeney resign him, he doled out a princely figure to a bottom pair D-man at best or even a healthy scratch on a good team, inking Miller to a ridiculous four-year $10 million contract. The move was lambasted by fans on social media.
Miller also is completely counter to the type of modern, speedy puck-control mobile defenseman the league is trending to and the Bruins are in need of to complement Torey Krug, the B's top puck mover and playmaker from the blueline who finished in the top 20 among league defensemen with a career-high 44 points. Krug also was among the Bruins' puck possession leaders, finishing second only to Patrice Bergeron in that category.
Every stat regarding Miller runs against this trend, not to mention the horrendous highly visible turnovers in nationally televised games. Although his overall play improved a bit in the latter portion of the season, Miller still finished with a lousy Corsi at 44.4% (shots and missed shots for versus against while on the ice) and 33 turnovers on the year - numbers that show he's not at all the type of puck possession guy the Bruins are looking for to help them push the pace, keep it out of their own end and control it into the opposing team's zone.
He did finish with 164 hits and 123 blocks, but those can also be indicative of having to defend often in one's own end and not being able to break it out cleanly and consistently to the forwards.
In 71 games, he finished a respectable +15 with 5 goals an 13 assists and at 6'2", 210 pounds adds a physical presence as well as a willingness to drop the gloves, but he will turn 29 in November and the contract just seems two years too long and a million per year too much.
Miller is also essentially a carbon copy of another 29-year old B's defenseman - Adam McQuaid, who was locked up for 4 years at $11 million last summer. McQuaid is also poor at possession and breakouts, finishing with a 43.4% Corsi and 27 giveaways in 64 games, but at 6'4", 212 pounds brings hits (142) and a willingness to block shots (121) and fight when needed. Tying up $21 million into two guys who will be well into their 30s by mid-contract and who are bottom pair defenders is duplicative and makes little roster-building sense. They are more of an indication of the B's still being stuck in a bygone era when size and brawn was more valued than it is in today's high-flying speed game.
The Bruins could have instead waited it out a little more on Miller, saved the money and tried to take a serious run at top UFA defensemen like Alex Goligoski or Keith Yandle. They still could.
"I think we need to look for another transitional D-man. We need to continue to transition the puck better.' - Bruins GM Don Sweeney
Even with Miller in the fold Boston is still in need of a second defenseman this offseason, and more of the puck-moving variety to give the Bruins mobility in the lineup in addition to Krug. Especially with Zdeno Chara, 39, (46.4 Corsi and 87 turnovers) and Dennis Seidenberg, who turns 35 in July and had just a 42.9 Corsi, falling prey to the same types of breakout struggles at times as Miller and McQuaid.
“I think we need to look for another transitional D-man,” said GM Don Sweeney on the Bruins website. "We’re also looking outside, at the marketplace (through free agency or trade), because we need to continue to transition the puck better.”
If the B's let winger Loui Ericksson, who had a good season in a contract year but will turn 31 in July, walk in free agency and another team overpay him this offseason, they could take that money saved and try to make a serious run at a D-man in free agency or see if some of their defense prospects are ready come camp time. They also still need to resign restricted free agents Krug and Colin Miller. The latter may be the Bruins' best internal answer as the secondary puck control defenseman to support Krug since he's got good speed, a good shot and possession numbers (54.5 Corsi and 16 points in only 42 games).
“We’ve had talks with [impending restricted free agent] Torey [Krug] and we’ll find, whatever term that ends up being, we’ll find a contract for him," Sweeney continued. "But we’re looking for balance. We’re also looking for players like Colin Miller to take the next step. We’ve got younger players that will hopefully push, and that’s what you want.
The Bruins mid-first round draft position actually may end up offering better value on offensive prospects at that point rather than on the blueline, so going all in on the Kevan Miller signing is just another head scratcher in a long series of them since the B's lost the Cup in 2013. Trading Tyler Seguin, Dougie Hamilton and Johnny Boychuck, missing out on key prospects in the draft, dealing away too many picks, mishandling assets and resigning 4th liners and journeymen role players to bloated multi-million dollar contracts are among some of the others.
It would be great to see an exciting, skilled fast young team out on the ice with a couple superstars and elite scoring, but it remains to be seen whether the B's will get there anytime soon when their first, most urgent and seemingly biggest priority was throwing $10 million at a 5-6 level defenseman.
UPDATE: 2016 NHL DRAFT Notes... The Bruins management and scouts continued this mind-boggling trend in the 2016 NHL draft when they bypassed on right-shooting, gritty 1st round-ranked dynamic scorers 5'7" RW Alex DeBrincat and 6'1" C/RW Pascal Laberge with their 29th pick to go way off the board and instead select big defensive center Trent Frederic who was projected to go in the mid to late second round (he was ranked from 47 to 58 on major draft boards). While Frederic projects to be a third or fourth line center down the road at the NHL level, DeBrincat (three straight 50-goal, 100-point seasons) and Laberge (tough two-way player who can both score and make plays) are legit first rounders who have the potential to be top-six forwards and would have been excellent value picks at number 29. Frederic could have been taken much later in the draft. The Bruins did take solid value players with both their 14th overall pick and 2nd rounder in defensemen Charlie McAvoy and Ryan Lindgren, but seem to continue to take one step forward and two steps back in a league that is quickly getting faster and more skilled and just don't seem to be on top of things when it comes to scouting or managing assets. Giving up all of the picks they did in last season's deadline trades (including their 2016 3rd and 4th rounders) instead of moving veteran assets for more picks also hurt them in the draft, where they ultimately ended up with only six selections. After going well off the board in the first round of the 2015 draft, as well, and passing on elite prospects such as Kyle Connor, who has gone on to become one of the top NHL prospects in the country, the Bruins' leadership continues to be a cause for concern to the team's fanbase as the B's seemingly continue to miss out on exciting players while the rest of the league scoops them up and seems to be quickly passing Boston by.